
Identity Guard Credit Monitoring
With monthly updates from Experian, Transunion, and Equifax, Identity Guard worked to keep us on top of our credit scores and reports.
- Identity theft protection powered by IBM® Watson™ AI
- Impressive $1 million in identity theft insurance
- Multiple service levels, from basic to advanced

They say the only things guaranteed in life are death and taxes, but we think credit should be added to that list. Your credit score can greatly affect your life, from getting a loan to buying a new home or leasing that shiny new car you have your eyes on. And there’s nothing you can do to avoid getting a credit score just like you can’t avoid death and taxes.
What’s scary about your credit score though is that there can be errors. According to the Federal Trade Commission, 26% of people found potential errors in their credit reports from the three bureaus, Experian, Transunion, and Equifax,1 which is why it’s important to stay on top of your credit. Identity Guard aims to help with that issue by monitoring your credit for you and sending alerts of any suspicious activity. Does it work though? Well, our identity protection experts tested out Identity Guard themselves to find out. Here’s what we learned.
Credit Monitoring with Identity Guard
To get complete credit monitoring from the three bureaus mentioned above, you have to sign up for the Total or Ultra plans. When we reviewed Identity Guard, we signed up for the Ultra plan to test out all the features available, but the Total plan will get you a monthly credit score and will alert you to any changes in your credit. However, to get the full report, the Ultra plan is essential. Keep in mind that checking your credit score won’t affect your credit in any way,2 so there’s no harm in checking monthly as opposed to annually.
Identity Guard’s Additional Features
Aside from credit monitoring, the Total and Ultra plans include a few other features to protect our identities online, from a dark web scan to change-of-address monitoring to financial account monitoring. Let’s talk about exactly what those features entail:
- Dark web scan: Billions of stolen passwords are bought and sold every day on the dark web, which is the seedy underbelly of the internet that is only accessible through special software where all of the users are anonymous. Identity Guard scanned the dark web to make sure our credentials were safe, alerting us if they were found so we could change our passwords ASAP.
- Address monitoring: You might not know this, but USPS lets people request a change of address to reroute their mail. There aren’t many safeguards in place either to prevent someone from changing your mailing address. By doing that, they can get your mail which might contain your personal or financial account information. That’s why Identity Guard includes address monitoring.
- Risk management report: Identity Guard gave us a score that showed how at risk we are for identity fraud. Our score? An almost perfect 98, not to brag!
- Safe browsing tools: Identity Guard also throws in some cybersecurity features that we didn’t get with other identity monitoring services. Their browser extension protected us against phishing, ads, tracking, data mining, and more.
- Bank account takeovers: If anyone tried to take over our bank accounts, we’d be notified. Identity Guard monitors for suspicious logins in order to catch account takeovers before the hacker can cause chaos in your life. Remember though, nothing’s 100 percent effective.
- Checkings or savings accounts: Say someone tried to open a checking or savings account using our information; we’d be notified as soon as Identity Guard detected it.
- Tax refund alerts: If anyone used our Social Security numbers on tax refunds, we’d know about it as soon as Identity Guard does.
- Social insight report: Finally, Identity Guard even analyzed our Facebook to check that our online image was one we wanted to portray. They did this using artificial intelligence technology from IBM® Watson™, which was pretty cool.
In a nutshell? If Identity Guard detected anything out of the ordinary regarding our credentials, we’d get alerted. But that doesn’t mean that we were 100% protected from identity theft, as no service can guarantee total prevention. Rather, Identity Guard gave us identity theft insurance, so if our identities were stolen, we could’ve been reimbursed for up to $1 million. This is typical of identity monitoring services, so Identity Guard certainly makes the cut.
Identity Guard Subscriptions
When it comes to signing up for Identity Guard, you can choose between the Total and Ultra packages to get credit monitoring, with Ultra including the full reports. Plans are available on a monthly or annual basis, with options for individuals as well as families, which covers all adults and children living in one house. To save money, choose the annual plan. Although you’ll have to pay a larger sum upfront, over a year’s time, you’ll save 17%, putting more money back into your pocket. Go deeper into your subscription options on our Identity Guard pricing page.
Feature | Value | Total | Ultra |
---|---|---|---|
401k and Investment Account Monitoring | No | No | Yes |
Annual Credit Report from 3 Bureaus | No | No | Yes |
Bank Account Monitoring | No | Yes | Yes |
Bank Account Monitoring | No | No | Yes |
Credit and Debit Card Monitoring | No | No | Yes |
Credit Monitoring from 3 Bureaus | No | Yes | Yes |
Criminal and Sex Offense Monitoring | No | No | Yes |
Customer Support Based in the U.S | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Dark Web Monitoring | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Data Breach Notifications | Yes | Yes | Yes |
High-Risk Transaction Monitoring | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Home Title Monitoring | No | No | Yes |
Identity Theft Insurance with $1 Million Maximum Reimbursement | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Monthly Credit Score from 1 Bureau | No | Yes | Yes |
Risk Management Report | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Safe Browsing Tool | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Social Media Insights Report | No | No | Yes |
USPS Address Change Monitoring | No | No | Yes |
White Glove Resolution Concierge | No | No | Yes |
Monthly plan for individuals (cost per month) | $8.99 | $19.99 | $29.99 |
Yearly plan for individuals (cost per month) | $6.67 | $11.99 | $17.99 |
Total amount billed for individual annual plan | $80.04 | $143.88 | $215.88 |
Monthly plan for families (cost per month) | $14.99 | $29.99 | $39.99 |
Yearly plan for families (cost per month) | $10.00 | $17.99 | $23.99 |
Total amount billed for family annual plan | $120.00 | $215.88 | $287.88 |
To get credit monitoring for an individual, you can either pay $19.99 a month or about $145 per year, but for the credit reports, the cost jumps up to $29.99 a month or about $215 for the whole year.
FYI: To get credit reports from all three bureaus, a.k.a the most comprehensive credit monitoring available, you’ll need to buy the Ultra Plan.
Can you try Identity Guard for free? Well, yes and no. Sometimes, the company offers 30-day money-back guarantees, but currently, there’s no free trial. One option is to sign up for an annual subscription and cancel within 30 days to receive a refund; however, you’ll still have to shell out a decent amount of money upfront, which is probably not ideal for most people. If you’re unsure about Identity Guard, we recommend signing up for a monthly package and then canceling within that period if you don’t like it. Learn more about your free trial options, which may change as time goes on.
Is My Data Safe with Identity Guard?
In order for Identity Guard to truly protect us, we had to give them a ton of data, from our birthdays to our home addresses to our bank account information. If you’ve turned on the news recently, you’ve probably seen a dozen or more security breaches from large tech companies, so keeping your data safe is always a concern. So, what does Identity Guard do to protect your data?
Firstly, Identity Guard encrypted our data using 128-bit encryption, which was a bit disappointing as the industry standard is 256-bit. And when we checked out their privacy policy, we found that they may share our information with third parties, although this wasn’t for marketing or advertising purposes. On top of that, since Identity Guard is based in the United States, they could be forced to hand the federal government our data, given the jurisdiction of Five Eyes, Nine Eyes, and 14 Eyes. In sum? If you’re super concerned about privacy, Identity Guard definitely isn’t your best bet. To explore other options, read our page on the best identity theft protection, or, if you have a family, the best identity theft protection for families.
Need Help With Identity Guard? Here’s What To Do
If you’re having trouble with Identity Guard, your best bet is to call their phone support directly. On weekdays, they’re available from 8 AM until 11 PM, and on Saturdays, they’re available from 9 AM until 6 PM EST. You can also email them or check out their online FAQs, but we found the FAQs to be a bit lacking in terms of comprehensiveness.
For Classic accounts, email customersupport@identityguard.com, but for Watson accounts, email customercare@identityguard.com. If you just bought a new Identity Guard subscription and are not sure which it is, it’s Watson; Classic accounts are supported but no longer sold by Identity Guard.
Tip: While Classic accounts use the Identity Guard Classic app, Watson accounts use the regular Identity Guard app.
Is It Worth It?
Considering that victims of identity theft lost an average of $7,761,3 Identity Guard can most likely pay for itself if your identity is stolen. Plus, we love that they have plans for individuals and families, which cover all of the adults and children in one household. Identity Guard will make it easy to stay on top of your credit, which is a good indicator of identity theft. But just who is Identity Guard ideal for?
Buy Identity Guard if you’d like…
- Credit scores and reports from all three bureaus: With the Ultra plan, you’ll get updates from Experian, Transunion, and Equifax including full reports.
- Identity theft and cybersecurity protection: Identity Guard not only monitors your identity, but it also gives you some more protection from your computer and mobile device.
- Identity theft insurance: Get up to $1 million in reimbursement if your identity is stolen while using Identity Guard.
But don’t get it if you were looking for…
- Better privacy: From its 128-bit encryption to its iffy privacy policy, Identity Guard isn’t the best service we’ve tested when it comes to privacy.
- Free trial: Currently, Identity Guard doesn’t offer a free trial, so you’ll have to pay some money upfront to use it.
- Most comprehensive identity monitoring available: Even though Identity Guard covers the basics, we’ve reviewed other identity monitoring services that cover more areas.
Want to learn even more about Identity Guard? Check out our pages on their app and spouse coverage, or read our comparisons of Identity Guard versus IdentityForce or Infoarmor.
FTC. (2012). Report to Congress Under Section 319 of the Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions Act of 2003.
ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/reports/section-319-fair-and-accurate-credit-transactions-act-2003-fifth-interim-federal-trade-commission/130211factareport.pdfTransUnion. (2020). How Often Should I Check Credit Score?.
transunion.com/article/how-often-should-I-check-credit-scoreBJS. (2017). Victims of Identity Theft, 2014.
bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/vit14.pdf